Thursday, October 3, 2013

Tuck Everlasting Discussion

End of book discussion question...

If you could ask Winnie one question about her life or decisions, what would it be and why?

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

We would ask Winnie why she didn't drink the water and marry Jesse because she wasn't interested in finding the Tucks. For example, she dumped the water on the toad. In addition, she married another man with the last name of Jackson. Maverick, Robyn, Cameron

Meghan Cannon-Johann said...

If we could ask Winnie a question , we would ask her why she hadgive the magic spring water to a toad instead of drinking it and living forever.
This is because we both think that she should have saved it until she was seventeen, then drank it to live forever.

Meghan Cannon-Johann said...

If we could ask Winnie a question , we would ask her why she hadgive the magic spring water to a toad instead of drinking it and living forever.
This is because we both think that she should have saved it until she was seventeen, then drank it to live forever.

Anonymous said...

If I could ask Winnie about her choices in life I would ask why she didn't drink the water.I would want to know why she used it on the toad instead of living and being with Jesse forever.
Phoenix and Isabella

Unknown said...

If I could ask Winne any question about her life I would ask her why she didn't drink the spring water.For example she could have lived forever,married Jesse,and live happily forever.

Julianne Sam

Anonymous said...

If we could ask Winnie a question about her life or her decisions , we would ask her why she sacrificed her immortality to the toad instead of herself.

- Jonathan and Sofia

Anonymous said...

If I could Winnie one question about her life or decisions I would ask her why she did not drink from the bottle Jesse had given her because she could have lived forever with the Tucks. For example she could have seen the world change and she could have seen the generations of modern technology. Zach and Shailen

Unknown said...

One life lesson you can learn from the story is that you should move on and accept your fate.For example people may miss you and you may change but life moves on.

Meghan Cannon-Johann said...

If we could ask Winnie a question about her life or decisions, we would ask her why she decided to give the spring water to the toad instead of herself and living forever.

-Jonathan and Sofia

Anonymous said...

If we could ask Winnie one question are question would be why she didnt drink from the spring water. We would ask her this question because it seemed like she was in love with Jesse and they could have lived forever together.
Eva Jackson

Anonymous said...

If we could ask a question to Winnie we would ask why didn't she go to the spring and drink the water and look for the tucks to marry Jesse. As a child she thought it was a wonderful idea so what made her change her mind?
Ananya and Caleb

Unknown said...

If I could ask Winnie a question about her life or decisions I would ask her why she did not drink the bottle Jesse gave her because she could have lived forever with the Tuck family. For example she could have seen the world change.
Zach and Shailen.